top of page

Why Reality Orientation Therapy Doesn’t Belong in Dementia Groups

4 minutes ago
5 min read
A Dementia Group Orientation Session
A Dementia Group Orientation Session

Imagine walking into a support group, just wanting a cup of tea and a chat with some people who understand what you're going through. You haven't even sat down when someone's pointing at the whiteboard and asking you to give them the day of the week, the current Prime Minister and the weather.


As someone living with young-onset dementia, I can tell you that doesn't feel like support. It feels like an exam you've not revised for.


This is Reality Orientation Therapy. It's a rather dubious approach which has been around for decades, and yet it still manages to find its way into dementia groups and care homes all over the place. Here's what it is, where it comes from and why it's actually a very bad idea.


What is Reality Orientation Therapy?

Reality Orientation (RO) was developed in the late 1950s/60s, initially as a way of helping the confused war veteran to re-orient himself in the world. It's based on the principle of constant re-orientation with regard to time, place and person.

In a group setting, this usually looks like:


  • Start off every session with a welcome board which will have the date, the season, the location , and the upcoming holidays on it.

  • Facilitators will quite gently (or not so gently in some cases) be correcting the members when they've got a fact wrong or think they're in a different time of their lives.

  • Quizzing people on current news headlines in order to keep them 'grounded' in the present day.


On the surface, it sounds completely innocuous. The theory was that by repeatedly feeding someone the right facts, you could retrain their brain and reduce the confusion.


Why It Fails in Dementia Groups

The issue is that dementia isn't just a case of simply forgetting to check your calendar. It's a progressive physical condition which affects the way the brain works in terms of processing, storing and retrieving information.


You can't just drill facts back into a brain that is physically changing in that way, no matter how many times you write the date on a whiteboard.

When facilitators force reality orientation onto a dementia group, it causes real damage to the people in the room:

  • It really does highlight what we've lost. A good peer group should be about what we can still do, our sense of humour, our humanity. Starting off by testing your short term memory immediately brings home your cognitive deficit. Getting the day of the week wrong in front of a room full of people is the epitome of embarrassment and it's the first thing that erodes your confidence before the conversation has even got going.

  • It induces all sorts of unnecessary anxiety and withdrawal. You're in a state of constant correction and it's very stressful. Rather than being able to just let your hair down and get on with it, you're in a state of perpetual vigilance where you're constantly on the lookout for the wrong thing to say. Eventually people just stop speaking up and in the end they stop attending altogether to avoid the stress.

  • It destroys peer equality. Dementia groups work at their best when everyone is on a level playing field and sharing experience as equals. The moment the facilitator starts going through the news and the weather with the group, that dynamic is completely gone. You've gone from having a supportive adult group to having a classroom situation, with a teacher lecturing a group of children.

  • It completely ignores the emotional truth and, in fact, causes fresh grief. If someone in the group says they need to collect their kids from school and you correct them by saying "Your kids are forty", you're not grounding them in reality at all. You're just forcing them to go through the experience of the shock, the confusion, and the grief of realising that time has passed, again and again throughout the afternoon.

  • It’s all about wellbeing, really. The fact that it's a rainy Tuesday in November doesn't in any way improve your quality of life. What matters in a support group is that you feel safe, you feel heard, and you feel valued. To be obsessed with factual accuracy at the expense of a person's emotional wellbeing is to miss the point entirely.

What Works Instead

Dementia groups don't need whiteboards and memory tests. They need connection, they need dignity and they need validation.

Validation therapy and a person centred approach will meet people where they are rather than drag them into a reality which no longer makes any sense to their brain.


If someone is concerned about getting home to their parents, a good facilitator will explore the feeling behind that rather than get into the facts. They might find that the concern is really about a need for safety and comfort.


If you're running a group and want to get rid of the welcome board, here are three sensible things you could do instead:


  • Use everyday objects as conversation starters. Bring in a box of tactile things (old coins, old postcards, a spade or two, a vinyl record, etc.). Just get people to hold them, pass them around, and see what comes out of it. There's no right or wrong answer,, and the use of a sensory object will lead to some very genuine stories without anyone feeling the need to be on the spot at all.

  • Play 'Pass the Playlist' instead of a news quiz. Swap the current affairs quiz for a shared playlist. Ask each person to pick a song that makes them happy or a song that takes them back to a good time, and then play it for the room. It's a great way to tap into emotional memory, get the energy of the room up and allows people to share who they are in a way that goes beyond their diagnosis.

  • Start with a "Favourite Things" check-in rather than asking people what day it is. Ask an opinion question that everyone can answer off the top of their head. "What's the best meal you've ever eaten?" "What's your favourite place to walk?" "What makes you laugh?" Opinions can't be wrong so you instantly get everyone on an equal footing.


A Challenge for Group Facilitators

Living with young-onset dementia means navigating enough tests in neurology clinics and memory assessments. When we come together as a community, we shouldn't have to prove we know what day it is just to earn a seat at the table.

If you facilitate a dementia group, take a hard look at how you open your next session. Put the whiteboard away, skip the date check, and ask your members what they actually want to talk about.


Better yet, invite people living with dementia to co-design your sessions from a blank page.


You'll quickly see the anxiety leave the room, replaced by genuine conversation, laughter, and real peer support.

 
 
 

Comments

Rated 0 out of 5 stars.
No ratings yet

Add a rating
bottom of page